Investigating the modelling uncertainties associated with the generation of flood projections

Extreme flood events continue to be one of the most threatening natural disasters around the world due to their pronounced social, environmental and economic impacts. Changes in the magnitude and frequency of floods have been documented during the last years, and it is expected that a changing climate will continue to affect their occurrence. Therefore, understanding the impacts of climate change through hydroclimatic simulations has become essential to prepare adaptation strategies for the future. However, the confidence in flood projections is still low due to the considerable uncertainties associated with their simulations, and the complexity of local features influencing these events. The main objective of this doctoral thesis is thus to improve our understanding of the modelling uncertainties associated with the generation of flood projections as well as evaluating strategies to reduce these uncertainties to increase our confidence in flood simulations. To address the main objective, this project aimed at (1) quantifying the uncertainty contributions of different elements involved in the modelling chain used to produce flood projections and, (2) evaluating the effects of different strategies to reduce the uncertainties associated with climate and hydrological models in regions with diverse hydroclimatic conditions. A total of 96 basins located in Quebec (basins dominated by snow-related processes) and Mexico (basins dominated by rain-related processes), covering a wide range of climatic and hydrological regimes were included in the study. The first stage consisted in decomposing the uncertainty contributions of four main uncertainty sources involved in the generation of flood projections: (1) climate models, (2) post-processing methods, (3) hydrological models, and (4) probability distributions used in flood frequency analyses. A variance decomposition method allowed quantifying and ranking the influence of each uncertainty source on floods over the two regions studied and by seasons. The results showed that the uncertainty contributions of each source vary over the different regions and seasons. Regions and seasons dominated by rain showed climate models as the main uncertainty source, while those dominated by snowmelt showed hydrological models as the main uncertainty contributor. These findings not only show the dangers of relying on single climate and hydrological models, but also underline the importance of regional uncertainty analyses. The second stage of this research project focused in evaluating strategies to reduce the uncertainties arising from hydrological models on flood projections. This stage includes two steps: (1) the analysis of the reliability of hydrological model’s calibration under a changing climate and (2) the evaluation of the effects of weighting hydrological simulations on flood projections. To address the first part, different calibration strategies were tested and evaluated using five conceptual lumped hydrological models under contrasting climate conditions with datasets lengths varying from 2 up to 21 years. The results revealed that the climatic conditions of the calibration data have larger impacts on hydrological model’s performance than the lengths of the climate time series. Moreover, changes on precipitation generally showed greater impacts than changes in temperature across all the different basins. These results suggest that shorter calibration and validation periods that are more representative of possible changes in climatic conditions could be more appropriate for climate change impact studies. Following these findings, the effects of different weighting strategies based on the robustness of hydrological models (in contrasting climatic conditions) were assessed on flood projections of the different studied basins. Weighting the five hydrological models based on their robustness showed some improvements over the traditional equal-weighting approach, particularly over warmer and drier conditions. Moreover, the results showed that the difference between these approaches was more pronounced over flood projections, as contrasting flood magnitudes and climate change signals were observed between both approaches. Additional analyses performed over four selected basins using a semi-distributed and more physically-based hydrological model suggested that this type of models might have an added value when simulating low-flows, and high flows on small basins (of about 500 km2). These results highlight once again the importance of working with ensembles of hydrological models and presents the potential impacts of weighting hydrological models on climate change impact studies. The final stage of this study focused on evaluating the impacts of weighting climate simulations on flood projections. The different weighting strategies tested showed that weighting climate simulations can improve the mean hydrograph representation compared to the traditional model “democracy” approach. This improvement was mainly observed with a weighting approach proposed in this thesis that evaluates the skill of the seasonal simulated streamflow against observations. The results also revealed that weighting climate simulations based on their performance can: (1) impact the floods magnitudes, (2) impact the climate change signals, and (3) reduce the uncertainty spreads of the resulting flood projection. These effects were particularly clear over rain-dominated basins, where climate modelling uncertainty plays a main role. These finding emphasize the need to reconsider the traditional climate model democracy approach, especially when studying processes with higher levels of climatic uncertainty. Finally, the implications of the obtained results were discussed. This section puts the main findings into perspective and identifies different ways forward to keep improving the understanding of climate change impacts in hydrology and increasing our confidence on flood projections that are essential to guide adaptation strategies for the future.